Analysis: Freshfields’s Cleary coup
Four partners left the white-shoe outfit for the Magic Circle firm’s New York office.

Clockwise from top left: Ethan Klingsberg, Pamela Marcogliese, Paul Tiger, Meredith Kotler
Three M&A partners and a finance partner recently left Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton to join Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer in the Big Apple, making it the white-shoe firm’s fifth worldwide corporate/finance partner departure in October alone.
This isn’t just any team move. Ethan Klingsberg, who has longstanding experience in advising boards and bankers on complex, high-profile transactions, and who counts Lowe’s Companies and Verizon Communications among his client contacts, led the defection – and will be leading Freshfields’s M&A team in the US.
Pamela Marcogliese and Paul Tiger will join him Klingsberg in the M&A team; both are particularly well versed in defending corporates against shareholder activism, suggesting that Freshfields is making a serious board-side play in its long game to continue building credibility among corporate directors. The Magic Circle firm, renowned for M&A in the UK, has been seriously improving its profile for M&A in the US: it recently advised Starbucks on the $7.15bn sale of its global coffee and foodstuffs business to Nestlé, for example.
This is no doubt a successful coup, though news reports so far have failed to point out that this is a potentially practice-shaping move for Freshfields. The Cleary team – Klingsberg, Marcogliese and Tiger in particular – has been a market-leading defender of boards against activist giants such as Elliott Management. Freshfields, which did not previously have a particularly well-known shareholder activism practice, has made a serious inroad into an area that is only becoming more strategically important and well-compensated.
Also on the contentious corporate side, but more active in the courtroom, the highly regarded Meredith Kotler is joining Freshfields’s litigation department with a focus on M&A, securities and shareholder disputes.
Cleary, which has stuck to its lockstep compensation model in stark contrast to more aggressive firms’ eat-what-you-kill payment structure, will be nursing its corporate finance wounds. London-based partner Andrew Shutter, who played an active role in Greece’s debt negotiations in 2015, left after 22 years at the firm earlier this month.
The firm’s M&A practice, which was hardly entirely reliant on Klingsberg, still seems to be thriving: it is advising Alphabet, historically a Klingsberg client, on its announced $2.1bn purchase of Fitbit. It won’t be clear for another several months just how much the recent defections have hit Cleary’s practice.
Arjun Sajip
Supreme Court to Rule on Patent Terms European Copyright Directive: The No Alliance European Copyright Directive: The No Alliance
The European Commission’s approval of the copyright directive in April threw more gas on the fire. In a few years, the internet has become – among other things – the main market fo...
Brazil’s Best Counsel 2021 - Chapter Opening: Large-Scale Credit Recovery Brazil’s Best Counsel 2021 - Chapter Opening: Large-Scale Credit Recovery
Interview with Jean-Marie Laurent Josi, CEO at Cobepa Interview with Jean-Marie Laurent Josi, CEO at Cobepa
The long-serving boss of Cobepa, Jean-Marie Laurent Josi talks about the business model of a Belgian investment firm that is trusted by major European families, one which marries t...